Customer Loyalty

Rebuild Loyalty with Tailored Campaigns

With so many options on the market today, it’s no surprise that customer loyalty is harder to come by. When one product hits the shelves, ten similar ones follow, all claiming to be the best. Consumers now have the freedom to switch brands at the slightest inconvenience, leading to a decline in loyalty. In fact, only 69% of consumers reported loyalty to specific retailers in 2024, down from 77% in 2022. 

The silver lining? Winning back lost customers is well within reach. These customers already know your brand, and with the right strategy, you can remind them why they chose you in the first place.

Why Re-Engaging Matters

Winning back past customers is one of the smartest moves you can make. Here’s why:

• They’re already familiar with you. Past customers are 50% more likely to try a new product and spend 31% more than brand-new ones.
• Loyalty isn’t dead. Despite the increased competition, 77% of consumers say they’ve remained loyal to at least one brand for over a decade.

Your Blueprint for Winning Back Lost Customer

While not always the first channel that comes to mind when talking about win-back strategies, direct mail can be used as a reengagement and reactivation tool. However, reconnecting with lost customers takes more than a generic postcard. It requires a thoughtful strategy that speaks directly to their needs.

1. Know Why They Left
   • The first step is figuring out why they drifted away. Was it a pricing issue? A bad experience? Or did they simply forget about you amidst the competition? Use your CRM data to dig into their purchase history and preferences so you can address the root cause.

2. Make It Personal
   • No one responds to “Dear Valued Customer.” Use their name, reference their location, or highlight something specific about their relationship with your brand. A line like, “We’ve missed you, Alex! Here’s what’s new at our Philadelphia location,” feels intentional and relevant.

3. Offer Them Something Irresistible
   • What’s going to make them take action? Whether it’s a discount, loyalty perk, or exclusive deal on a specific item they’ve purchased in the past or recently looked at on your website, the offer needs to feel worth their time. Add urgency with phrases like, “Limited Time Only” or “Exclusive for Returning Customers.”

4. Make It Simple
   • Don’t make them work to come back. Use QR codes that take them straight to the deal or provide a clear URL to a personalized landing page. The easier it is, the better your chances.

Examples of Effective Strategies

Direct mail isn’t one-size-fits-all. It works because it’s flexible enough to meet the needs of different industries. Its versatility lets you craft campaigns that speak directly to your audience, no matter the industry.  

Retail

Don’t just send a generic discount. Make it personal and relevant. For instance, if a customer purchased hiking gear last year, send a postcard featuring exclusive discounts on fall jackets, boots, or camping essentials. Pair this with a QR code linking to a curated collection based on their past purchases or local outdoor events with the goal of becoming a trusted resource in their lifestyle.

Take it up a notch by offering something experiential, like a free workshop or demo day. Imagine a postcard reading, “Gear Up for Winter Adventures—Join Our Free Cold Weather Camping Clinic.” This creates engagement beyond the sale, strengthening their connection to your brand.

Restaurants

Generic “We Miss You” offers won’t work in this industry either. Think about how you can make your direct mail feel more personal. A local pizzeria could send a postcard that says, “Your favorite margherita pizza is waiting for you!” Include a QR code that lets them order it with one click and offers a free topping upgrade.

If your restaurant is known for seasonal menus, use direct mail to tease what’s new. A glossy postcard showcasing your winter specials with a note like, “Cozy up with our new truffle pasta—on us!” invites them back while highlighting what makes your menu special. Time it around local events, like a nearby festival or game night, to boost foot traffic when they’re already out and about.

Healthcare

Patients often need reminders to stay on track with their health, but those reminders should add value. A postcard reading, “Let’s Keep You Feeling Your Best,” paired with practical tips like, “5 Simple Ways to Stay Active This Winter,” positions you as a caring partner, not just a service provider.

For pediatricians, create campaigns that target specific milestones. For example, send reminders for school vaccinations or annual check-ups with playful designs that appeal to parents and kids. A note like, “Is your little one ready for the new school year? Schedule today!” makes it timely and relevant.

Gyms and Fitness Centers

Motivate past members with strategic timing. A postcard arriving in January could say, “[First Name], It’s Time to Hit Reset—2025 is Yours!” Include a QR code that directs them to book a free class or consultation.

Take it further by tying campaigns to their fitness journey. If you know a member used to attend yoga classes, send a targeted offer like, “[First Name], Your Mat Misses You—Enjoy 50% Off Your Next Yoga Session.” It shows you understand their preferences and makes rejoining feel effortless.

Subscription Services

Subscriptions are built on loyalty, but lost subscribers need more than a discount to come back. A meal kit service could send a postcard reading, “Stress-Free Meals Tailored to You,” highlighting affordable, healthy recipes customized to family size, dietary needs, and health goals. Include a QR code linking to a quiz for a personalized menu and a discount like $20 off their first box back.

For streaming services, re-engage with, “Your Watchlist Just Got Better,” showcasing fresh content tailored to their preferences. Pair this with a QR code linking to curated recommendations and a free trial to make reactivation seamless.

Final Thoughts

The key to effective direct mail is relevance. By tailoring each campaign to the audience’s specific needs, preferences, and behaviors, you create messages that resonate, drive action, and build long-term loyalty.

Ready to bring your customers back? Let’s create a campaign that turns lapsed shoppers into lifelong supporters.

Reach out today!

In a world dominated by digital interactions, a variety of businesses (especially grocers and retailers) are rediscovering the enduring impact of direct mail on customer engagement. Furthermore, businesses are catching wind that direct mail is where tradition meets innovation for loyalty campaigns. In this blog, we’ll delve into the strategic use of direct mail as a powerful tool for crafting and enhancing loyalty program marketing campaigns, and we’ll also be examining how its unique attributes can cater specifically to the needs of those in the grocery and retail sector. From creating tangible and personalized connections to celebrating customer milestones, we detail the diverse ways in which direct mail can shape a memorable and targeted loyalty campaign experience.

Benefits of Direct Mail for Loyalty Campaigns

Tangible and Personalized

Generally, direct mail can establish a tangible and personalized connection with each customer due to its physicality, elevating the overall customer experience and enhancing memorability. Unlike digital interactions, receiving and opening mail adds a sensory dimension to the engagement, making it more immersive. This tactile experience, coupled with personalized content tailored to individual preferences and purchase history, can foster a deeper connection and strengthen the emotional bond between customers and loyalty programs.

Highly Targeted

Direct mail enables precise targeting by leveraging customer purchase history, preferences, and demographics. This capability enhances the relevance of loyalty program messaging, ensuring that the content resonates with each individual recipient. By tailoring campaigns to specific characteristics and behaviors, companies can deliver personalized and meaningful communications, increasing the likelihood of customer engagement. The precision of direct mail targeting not only introduces the loyalty program effectively but also ensures that the message reaches the right audience with maximum impact.

Engaging

As touched on above, the targeted and tangible nature of direct mail prompts customers to actively engage with campaign messaging, and – even better, redeem their loyalty points. The physical presence of loyalty program materials can enhance the customer’s inclination to participate, and this active engagement, stimulated by the personalized and tactile aspects of direct mail, can contribute significantly to the success of your loyalty initiative.

For more retail marketing ideas, click here.

Common Strategies of Direct Mail for Loyalty Campaigns

Updates, Reminders, & Thank-Yous

Direct mail keeps customers engaged in loyalty programs through timely updates, personalized thank-you notes, and strategic reminders. It also provides customers with information about their loyalty points, program changes, and new features, ensuring they’re consistently informed and engaged.

Personalized thank-you notes sent via direct mail can create a memorable and emotionally resonant experience that strengthens the customer’s connection with the company and its loyalty program. Additionally, businesses can send timely reminders about upcoming expiration dates of loyalty points, encouraging customers to seize the opportunity to redeem their rewards before they expire.

Milestone & Exclusivity Incentives

Direct mail can reinforce customer loyalty through thoughtful celebrations and exclusive privileges. By celebrating customer milestones, such as reaching specific point thresholds, celebrating birthdays, or even acknowledging anniversaries of first purchases, businesses can add a personal touch. These are often accompanied by extra incentives to further encourage ongoing loyalty, such as a free gift or discount.

Direct mail’s also an ideal platform for announcing exclusive sales and events, offering customers early access and special privileges linked to their loyalty status. This not only fosters a sense of VIP treatment but also actively encourages customer participation.

Direct Mail for Loyalty Campaigns, In Action

Executing a successful loyalty campaign that includes direct mail involves implementing key strategies to enhance customer engagement and overall effectiveness. So, what’s the process here at Strata? Below you’ll find what we consider most important:

Personalized Content

Incorporating personalized content and utilizing customer data – such as addressing customers by name and tailoring messages based on their purchase history, preferences, and loyalty status.

Marketing Mix Integration

Integrating direct mail into the overall marketing mix for your loyalty campaign is often crucial for success. Most of the time, coordinating direct mail with digital and other marketing channels amplifies the impact.

Testing and Optimization

Implementing a testing and optimization strategy for any direct mail campaign helps companies refine their approach over time. A/B testing different elements, such as messaging, design, and incentives, can allow for identification of the most effective strategies for engaging customers and driving loyalty.

Before following the strategies and practices above, companies should understand the audience they’re targeting, what their goals are for their rewards and loyalty program(s), and what they want out of their customer loyalty marketing campaigns. With that said, it’s very likely the campaigns will benefit from personalized content, streamlined workflows, and integrated direct mail. With the use direct mail, grocers and retailers alike can create a targeted and memorable experience for their loyal customers. Contact Strata today to explore how our expertise can help take your loyalty or rewards program(s) to the next level.

A Strata YouTube Channel Original

Creating a personally relevant multichannel campaign can be difficult without proper preparation and guidance. Luckily, in this blog, featuring our most recent YouTube video of our Multichannel Marketing series, we go over some marketing personalization statistics, how to create a personalized, cohesive, and seamlessly relevant journey across multiple channels, and ways to better know who your buyers are. 

The key to starting is to understand who your audience is and their specific buyer journey. Once you collect this data, it’s time to personalize and make sure the content you’re putting in front of them is relevant.

Map Out Your Customer Journey

When creating the perfect multichannel campaign for your audience, take a look at who your buyers really are and then work backwards to figure out how they became a customer. What high-value acquisition channels did these customers use? Which customers have strong LTV (lifetime value)? Talk to your customer service team and your customers. Once you organize and map that out, you’ll have a much easier time figuring out where the problems are, and where objections are coming from. And finally, discover where customers dropped off in the funnel. Put all of this together, and you’ll have a clear look at the journey your customers take and how you can improve your connections with them.

Establish Your Data

When we say establish your data, we’re talking way more than first names and company names. While those are important – that’s not the personalization customers are looking for these days. You’ll want to start partnering with a company (or using software) that can help you gather info like real-time, on-site behavior, online and offline conversion history, geographic location, product affinities, and device activity. All of this will help you develop a strategy that’s consistent and relevant from one channel to the next.

Ultimately, there’s no one-size-fits-all personalized experience – that’s why customers crave it so much. To see what steps are next in establishing your personalized approach, click on the video below. You’ll hear our Marketing and Social Media Coordinator, Bridget, go through best practices. Or, if you’d like to discuss this concept with one of our multichannel experts, contact us today to get your next (or maybe even your first) multichannel campaign started.

A Strata YouTube Channel Original

Throughout your workday, you might hear the term “Multichannel Marketing” being thrown around casually, and not have the slightest clue of what it’s referring to. That’s okay! We understand that it can sound like an intimidating subject. While up to 95% of marketers say they understand the importance of multichannel marketing for targeting, only 73% say they hjave a multichannel strategy set in place. At its core, Multichannel Marketing is a simple concept that can help your company’s overall marketing campaigns and execution excel. Read along as we walk you through this falsely intimidating marketing concept.

What is Multichannel Marketing?

In a nutshell, multichannel marketing is a strategy that uses a combination of indirect and direct communication channels. With these channels, you’re able to reach all of your clients, prospects, and customers with a multifaceted campaign that can do wonders for your company. Multichannel campaigns are all about distributing the right content to the right people at the right time. Whether it’s by direct mail, digital ads, social, websites, or brick and mortar stores, multichannel marketing can be anywhere and everywhere so that your customers can take action and respond to the channel of their choice. You basically open a window of endless communication possibilities, and let your customers respond on their own terms. There’s no forced communication, because the advertising experience is controlled by the pace of the customer.

98% of Americans switch between multiple devices in one day. If that statistic isn’t enough to make you believe in multichannel marketing’s power, then we don’t know what is. Traditional marketing tactics work, but multichannel marketing is unique because it meets customers where they are along their journey instead of at one single spot. For this reason, multichannel marketing is never a “one size fits all” approach. It requires marketing readiness on multiple channels, especially since 86% of shoppers regularly channel-hop across a minimum of two mediums.

Ready to Learn More?

If we’ve piqued your interest and you’re ready to enhance your multichannel marketing knowledge, check out our YouTube channel or click the video below. Our Marketing Manager, Caitlin, will give you a quick three-minute explanation on this ever-popular topic, or if you’d like to discuss this concept with one of our multichannel experts, contact us today to get your next (or maybe your first) multichannel campaign started.